‘Unsolved Mysteries’ Volume 3: How Did Buffalo Jim Barrier Die? - Netflix Tudum

  • Deep Dive

    Are You Ready to Solve the Mystery of ‘Death in a Vegas Motel’?

    The Unsolved Mysteries bonus material for the case of “Buffalo Jim” Barrier, including photos, police reports and more.

    By Steve Helling
    Oct. 25, 2022

“Buffalo Jim” Barrier was known for his larger-than-life personality. A wrestling promoter and business owner, he was once voted Las Vegas’ most colorful character. But not everyone loved Buffalo Jim. After a long feud with strip club owner Rick Rizzolo, he began to receive death threats — much to the concern of his four daughters. 

On the morning of April 6, 2008, Buffalo Jim was found dead in a Motel 6 in Las Vegas. Police reports said he was lying face-up on the bed, nude from the waist down, with white powder on his nose, beard and shirt. The coroner said that his use of cocaine, combined with significant heart disease, had caused his heart to stop. The death was ruled accidental.

Related Stories

  • 28 Gripping True Crime Documentaries to Stream
    What to Watch "Crime" on a spashy red background.

But was it? Investigators soon learned that a woman known only as “Lisa” claimed she was in the room with Buffalo Jim when he started convulsing. The key card log for his motel room seemed to indicate that someone entered his room minutes before he checked in, and may have been waiting for him there. After his death, his car vanished, only to later reappear in the parking lot.

Friends and family members — and some investigators — now believe that Buffalo Jim was a victim of foul play, and point to the release of Rick Rizzolo from house arrest the day before Buffalo Jim died. What really happened to Buffalo Jim? Was his death truly accidental, or did something more sinister happen?

What Really Happened to Buffalo Jim? | Unsolved Mysteries V3E4

Before Buffalo Jim’s death, there were a series of mysterious break-ins at his auto body shop. Nothing was stolen, but who was responsible? In the video above, former Las Vegas City Councilman Steve Miller shares his theory. 

Photos of Buffalo Jim 

See scenes from Buffalo Jim’s colorful life, from parades and wrestling events to tender moments with his daughters. 

1 / 16
Buffalo Jim paid a local artist to create this custom-made animatronic buffalo that belched steam. He loved driving it through the streets of Las Vegas at the Helldorado Days parade each year. 
Jerica is Buffalo Jim’s youngest daughter and was his beloved “side-kick.” She was given the nickname “Lil’ Buff” by his friends. 
James Barrier, dressed in his full regalia as “Buffalo Jim,” was a popular Master of Ceremonies at WWF events in Las Vegas.  
Buffalo Jim loved being greeted by fans at every event he attended. The gold-colored metal vest was a treasured gift. 
Buffalo Jim at his auto shop, located next door to the Crazy Horse Too gentleman’s club. His collection of wrestling memorabilia covers the shop walls. 
Buffalo Jim’s home overlooking Las Vegas had an incredible view. His daughters say he loved to escape his busy life in the city.   
Buffalo Jim was proud of his home in Las Vegas because he was homeless when he first arrived in town as a young man.
Buffalo Jim riding a steaming buffalo at a Las Vegas wrestling club. His sense of humor and love for entertaining made him a popular guest. 
Buffalo Jim was a super fan of the wrestling world. Seen here with museum memorabilia from one of his all-time favorites, Muhammad Ali.
Buffalo Jim celebrated the September 6, 2006 closing of Rick Rizzolo’s Crazy Horse Too gentleman’s club by parking his signature buffalo float out in front. 
Buffalo Jim and one of his closest friends, WWF wrestler, Johny “Psycho” Paine, often attended local wrestling events together, usually cheering and egging each other on. 
Buffalo Jim, wearing his signature gear, treasured his vast collection of unique wrestling memorabilia, which filled both his home and auto shop. 
Buffalo with his daughter, Jennifer, on one of their frequent trips to Disneyland. The time he spent with his four daughters was what was most important to him. 
Buffalo Jim and Steve Miller, city councilman and journalist, took vacations together with their kids. 
Buffalo Jim and Steve Miller celebrated the September 6, 2006, closing of Rick Rizzolo’s Crazy Horse Too gentleman’s club by parking Buff’s signature buffalo out in front. 
One of Buffalo Jim’s closest friends, WWF wrestler, Johny “Psycho” Paine, was a frequent visitor to his auto shop, renowned locally for its wrestling memorabilia. 

Clues from the scene

See the items found in Buffalo Jim’s motel room after his death. What can they reveal? 

1 / 3
This mysterious silver phone was not listed in the LVMPD’s reported evidence list, and it wasn’t given to the family with the rest of Buffalo Jim’s belongings. His family does not know whose phone is in the photograph, where it came from, or what happened to it.  
Buffalo Jim’s wallet, ID, and a single dollar bill were found by police on the unoccupied bed next to his body. Family and friends believe that the lone dollar bill is a sign that this was a mob hit. 
These items were found with Buffalo Jim’s body in motel room 105: the room receipt, the room card key, a garage door opener, and his keys - including one to the Rolls Royce that he’d driven to the motel. The small black cell phone-shaped item was actually a toy. 

Download additional evidence

See more “Death in a Vegas Motel” bonus material, including police reports, the coroner’s report and surveillance video of Buffalo Jim on the night he died. 

Watch the episode

Watch “Death in a Vegas Motel” here. 

Got a tip? 

See something that might be important? Go to Unsolved.com and let us know.

Related Tags

All About Unsolved Mysteries

  • Are You Ready to Solve the Mystery of ‘Abducted by a Parent’?
    The ‘Unsolved Mysteries’ bonus material for the abductions of Amina Kandil, Belel Kandil and Aziz Khan.
  • Unsolved Mysteries is back and needs your help cracking four new cases. 
  • Unsolved Mysteries investigates the chilling murder of university student Sigrid Stevenson.
  • Unsolved Mysteries Volume 4, Episode 5 revisits a classic case as sightings continue to pile up.
  • Unsolved Mysteries explores the discovery of a decapitation in rural PA.
  • Unsolved Mysteries Volume 4, Episode 1 offers theories on the identity of the notorious serial killer.
  • Episode 2 of Unsolved Mysteries Volume 4 explores unanswered questions around Amanda Antoni’s death.

Shop Unsolved Mysteries

Go to Netflix Shop

Discover More Deep Dive

  • The Worst Ever franchise is back with deadly tales of the people next door.
  • Are you ready to step back into a world of pure imagination this fall?
  • New series Instadocs answers the burning questions on everyone’s minds.
  • The series features interviews with Becky Hill and witnesses from the 2023 trial. 
  • These celebs are going behind bars to earn their redemption.
  • The lore of Liam, Maggie’s husband, is finally revealed.
  • A new group of couples will soon be playing house with a trial spouse.
  • A father unleashes his secret skills when his daughter goes missing.

Related Videos

  • Paranormal activity, cold cases, and Roswell UFOs.
  • Multiple accounts of The Mothman attacks occurred in this Chicago neighborhood.
  • Unsolved Mysteries follows detectives as they discuss the crime scene.
  • The artist and educator explains her work in “The Severed Head.”
  • After Antoni’s murder in 2015, those close to her keep her legacy alive.
  • Detectives investigated 11 murders between April 1888 and February 1891.
  • Prepare for spine-tingling cases, eerie sightings, and historical horrors.
  • How a trip to Egypt in 2013 impacted his life.

Popular Now

  • Voicemails for Isabelle dials to the top, and Avatar: The Last Airbender debuts.
  • Stream Voicemails for Isabelle, Office Romance, a new season of Avatar: The Last Airbender, and more.
  • Meet the allies and enemies shaping Aang’s next chapter.
  • Zoë Kravitz, Sadie Sink, and Troy Baker star in a new immersive game experience.